Every manuscript submitted to The International Journal of Applied Operational Research (IJAOR) follows a structured editorial workflow. The main stages are as follows:
Step 1: Submission and Administrative Check
Upon submission, the editorial office performs an administrative check to ensure that the manuscript is complete, complies with the Author Guidelines, and includes the required similarity report (iThenticate). Incomplete submissions are returned to the authors.
Step 2: Initial Editorial Screening (Desk Evaluation)
The manuscript is assigned to a Handling Editor whose expertise best matches the subject of the paper. The Handling Editor evaluates whether the manuscript falls within the journal’s Aims and Scope and whether it meets the minimum standards of quality, originality, and methodological rigor. Manuscripts that fail this screening are desk-rejected without further review, normally within 1–2 weeks.
Step 3: Assignment of Reviewers
If the manuscript passes the initial screening, the Handling Editor assigns it to at least three independent external reviewers with recognized expertise in the relevant field. Reviewers are selected from the journal’s reviewer database and international experts, taking into account conflicts of interest.
Step 4: Peer Review Reports
Reviewers submit detailed reports together with a recommendation of one of the following actions:
- Accept (publish unaltered)
- Minor Revision (consider after minor changes)
- Major Revision (consider after major changes)
- Reject (the manuscript is flawed, out of scope, or not sufficiently novel)
Step 5: Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers’ reports, the Handling Editor makes one of the following decisions:
- Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication as submitted.
- Minor Revision: Authors are notified to submit a revised version addressing the reviewers’ minor comments. The Handling Editor evaluates the revision; once satisfied, the manuscript is accepted.
- Major Revision: Authors are asked to revise the manuscript substantially and resubmit it within a specified period. The revised manuscript is normally re-evaluated by the original reviewers, after which the Handling Editor may decide to accept, request a further (minor) revision, or reject.
- Reject: The rejection is final. Rejection is immediate if the Handling Editor finds the manuscript out of scope, of insufficient quality, plagiarized, or containing inaccurate results, or if two or more reviewers recommend rejection.
Step 6: Conflict Resolution among Reviewers
If reviewers’ recommendations are contradictory (e.g., one accept and one reject), the Handling Editor may request an additional independent reviewer’s opinion or seek the advice of an Associate Editor before making a final, balanced decision.
Step 7: Final Acceptance and Production
After acceptance, the manuscript enters the production stage: copy-editing, typesetting, final author proofreading, and assignment of a DOI prior to online publication.
Editorial Independence
The Handling Editor has full authority to reject any manuscript on grounds of inappropriateness of subject, lack of quality, plagiarism, or inaccurate results. An editor may not serve as an external reviewer of a manuscript he or she is handling. Any manuscript authored by the Editor-in-Chief, an Associate Editor, or an Editorial Board member is handled by an independent editor who is not affiliated with the author, in order to guarantee a fair and unbiased process. |